 |
Introduction
to the speaker
Patrick
Reynolds was the first tobacco industry figure to turn his back
on the cigarette makers. He's a grandson of the tobacco company
founder R.J. Reynolds, but the family's cigarette brands, Camel
and Winston, killed his father and eldest brother.
Since
first speaking out in Congress in 1986, Patrick has been a well
respected champion for a tobacco free society. In hundreds of
live talks before universities, middle schools and high schools,
and with over 6,000 copies of his educational
video purchased by schools and health departments, Mr. Reynolds
has reached well over a million youth in school with his powerful
talk about the dangers of tobacco.
"In
a little over an hour, Reynolds went from being just another
anti-tobacco speaker to something special," commented one
local paper. Recent news
articles about his appearances illustrate how his appearances
can bring the tobaccofree message to the whole community, and
build goodwill for sponsors.
A
short phone call to a local hospital will plant the idea with
its Community Relations Director to sponsor his talk. County
health departments and tobaccofree coalitions will often chip
in. Print out our Five
Minute Plan now and make one call!
See
the quotes from
teachers who saw him speak live. Mr. Reynolds also offers
a highly motivational lecture
program for universities.
Patrick
Reynolds is devoting his life to furthering the goal of
a smokefree society, and to motivating young people to stay
tobacco free.
A
text version of his talk for youth follows below.
The Truth
About Tobacco
Text of our live anti-smoking
assembly program
for grades 7-12
Additional
information included in the version below.
My father died from
smoking
I
want to begin today with a little story. My parents were divorced
when I was three, and for six long years, I didn't see my Dad.
Now a boy needs his Dad to come to the football game and say, "You
played well, son. I'm proud of you you're my boy!" He
needs his Dad's hugs, encouragement, guidance and love. I didn't
have that, and it was hard for me. A girl needs her Dad, too.
Some of
you in the audience do not have your biological father living
at home with you, and you share the situation I remember. How
do you feel about that? Are you angry, or sad, or maybe
a little afraid, not having him around as much as you would like?
Or a combination of feelings?
Today
we're going to spend some of our time taking about our feelings.
How did I feel? At times, I felt angry, sad and afraid
without my
Dad around.
For
six years, I really missed him. When I was nine, I got the idea
to write him a letter. It said, 'Dear Dad I want to
meet you. Where are you?' He was traveling at the time,
and amazingly, my little letter was forwarded seven times from
city to city. By a miracle, it got into his hands and he sent
for me. I remember the day I first got word that he wanted to
meet me, and I was jumping up and down with joy.
When
the big day came at last, and they showed me into the room where
he was, I was saddened to find my Dad lying down, on his back,
gasping for breath. He was dying from emphysema, caused by smoking
the cigarettes that made our family wealthy.
I
only got to see him on five visits after that, and every time,
he was increasingly sick and frail, and counting the time he
had left to live.
My
Dad died from smoking I was 15, and that was hard. Later, my
aunt and oldest brother would die because they smoked. That's
why I chose to totally turn my back on my family's former tobacco
business and walk away and to do everything in my power
to connect with young people, and persuade them to stay tobaccofree.
I
also did it because doing this work, I have been able to make
a difference. It's feels wonderful to contribute to the lives
of others to be of service.
So
those are two reasons I chose to devote my life to the tobaccofree
cause. In 1989 I founded The Foundation for a Smokefree America,
and I'll dedicate myself to this work for the rest of my life.
Tobacco Is Extremely
Addicting
If
I could give you just one message today, it would be this: smoking
is extremely addicting. Once you start, you may not be able to
stop ever. And the same is true for drugs and alcohol.
I
can't emphasize this enough some of you may not ever be
able to stop, if you start smoking or chewing tobacco.
How
long does it take to get hooked? A September 2000 study showed
that one quarter of 11 to 13 year olds who smoke as few as
two or three cigarettes a day become addicted in just two
weeks. And many of the rest got addicted shortly after
that.
Once
hooked, the average smoker is unable to stop for seventeen
years! And every year, they will spend $1200 or more on tobacco
products, to maintain their addiction.
What
could you buy with the money you would save in two years? How
about your first car! Over
10 years, you would save $12,000!
Photo by
Visible Light / Mickey
Krakowski
The Addiction
Let's
look at someone trying to quit smoking. For most addicted smokers,
the addition is about half-mental, half-physical. This varies
with each individual.
The
physical portion of the addiction is to nicotine. The psychological
part of the addiction is to the relaxing, familiar sensation
of handling the cigarette, watching its curling smoke, the deep
and relaxing breathing associated with inhaling and exhaling,
the taste, and so on.
When
quitting, a smoker's conscious mind says, "I will stop smoking no
problem." But the unconscious mind has been conditioned that
cigarettes give pleasure, and that's all it can focus on.
The
addicted, unconscious mind says, 'Give me a cigarette now!'
It only recognizes what feels good, or what doesn't feel good.
It demands a cigarette without regard to right or wrong, and
rebels against the conscious mind's decision to not smoke.
During
the process of quitting, however, a new habit of being a nonsmoker
forms. The unconscious mind gradually gets used to not smoking,
and the urges to smoke die away. [See our cool Quitting
Tips for more information on how to quit smoking.]
Quitting
Once
they get addicted, nearly all smokers try to stop a number of
times. But most fail repeatedly at quitting, and many are never
able to stop smoking.
Reality
check: there is no product which works well. 85 out of every
100 quitters using the nicotine patch or gum go back to smoking
within a year. Once
you are hooked, there's
just no easy way out.
For
smokers who quit without being in a program, it's worse — 95
out of 100 of them fail, and return to the habit within a year.
The
lesson is clear. With no program, statistically smokers have
only a 5% chance of success. With a program, the average quitter's
chances increase to 15%. So getting into a program increases
your chances of quitting by three times.
Not
trying at all, of course, means that nothing will change.
If
you are smoking now or using chew tobacco, I urge you to first
admit to yourself that maybe you are smoking less out of choice,
and more because you are addicted. Later, when you make a clear
and firm decision to stop, getting support from a good program
will ease your way and lighten your burden. In short, get help.
Real men ask directions
People
who are the most successful at living life typically get plenty
of help. For example, in business, a successful businesswoman
or businessman gets a lawyer to write the contracts, an advertising
agency to create the ads, a marketing executive to do the marketing,
an accountant to do the accounting, a doctor when they're sick people
who succeed best get help, and lots of it. Even the greatest
novelists have editors they count on for their invaluable feedback.
Students
often get mentors, adults who look after and guide their careers,
and share their knowledge. Ask an adult you admire and trust
to be your mentor. They might say no, but don't give up — ask
someone else. Choose someone with high morals and ethical standards,
and don't settle for less.
I
experimented with cigarettes as a teen. I never thought I'd get
addicted, but by age 18 I was completely hooked. For the next
17 years, I tried and tried again to quit. I failed a dozen times.
I finally quit smoking in 1985, and have stayed smokefree since
then. Quitting smoking was one of the hardest things I ever did.
In
summary, if
you are smoking, don't be afraid to get help. If you are using
tobacco now, or experimenting with it, see the school nurse or
talk to an adult.
Connecting
with others is a big theme today. It's okay to talk to
someone and get help. If you can't find anyone, get into an online
program. Check our free Quitting Tips page
for more info.
And
if you haven't started smoking yet, remember tobacco is extremely addicting.
You can get totally hooked much faster than you think.
The
best way to avoid getting addicted is simply to not smoke no
matter what.
Smoking in Movies and TV
In
the 1990's, there was a big upsurge in the amount of smoking
in films and TV. Characters in the movies were much more likely
to smoke than a person in real life, and so films misled many
teens into thinking that smoking was more popular than it really
was.
Too
many movie stars make smoking look cool to young people — and
children — who go to films. You might remember a star smoking
in a recent movie. If not, perhaps you will notice it next time
you see it.
I
want to open your eyes and empower you today. I want you to become conscious of
how the stars have set a bad example for our kids, by making
smoking look cool on screen.
Smokefree
America does not advocate censorship of movies. Instead, let's
deliver a dose of healthy shame to the actors who smoke in films,
and make it look cool to our kids. Then perhaps the stars will
think twice before they do it in future films. Shame on the producers,
too.
Which
stars have been smoking most in films? John Travolta smoked in
nearly every film he made in the 1990's. Julia Roberts smoked
in several of hers. So did Winona Ryder, Ethan Hawke, Gwenneth
Paltrow, Brad Pitt and others.
Young
people look up to stars and copy them. It's difficult to measure
the negative effect these actors have had on younger children.
Stars have a responsibility to lead our kids in a good direction,
not in a bad one.
Shame
on you folks! We expect more from you in the future.
We
uncovered this photo of an old
ad for Lark cigarettes with Pierce Brosnan. It was
seen in Japan. But Brosnan saw the error of his ways,
and has since shown some leadership in the Hollywood
community, when he vowed he would smoke no more as James
Bond. His turnabout set a good example for other stars,
and for youth who see him as James Bond. |
Charlie
Sheen's ad for Parliament ran in Japan. Mr. Sheen set
a bad example for Japanese youth who look up to him. |
For
more info, see our page,
Anti-smoking issues in TV and films.
Turning tobacco
ads into anti-tobacco ads
In
this powerful and motivating section of his anti-smoking assembly
program, Mr. Reynolds discusses tobacco advertising. The vivid
stories and facts he relates in his anti-tobacco talks are
designed to empower youth to resist the onslaught of cigarette
ads and peer pressure.
Using
the anti-smoking ads below, Patrick makes great fun of tobacco
advertising. He emphasizes that smoking looks very un-cool,
and is no longer socially acceptable.
Both
middle school and high school youth enjoy this section of his
anti-tobacco assembly program. Humor is a key ingredient of
his talks.
If cigarette
ads told the truth,
here's how they might look.
We've
all seen the ads for Marlboro Country, with images of beautiful
country scenes, wild horses galloping, and rugged, masculine
cowboys around a fire, or on horseback. Well, if tobacco ads
told the truth, here's what the real Marlboro Country might look
like:
Notice
that we see several smokers, outside their office building in
the cold, getting their fix of nicotine because they're
addicted. They're not welcome inside the building. People just
don't want to be around their smoke. Often it's not legal to
smoke indoors, because second hand smoke can seriously hurt others.
The
fact is, today almost four out of five people in the USA do not
smoke. Think about this: nowadays, being a nonsmoker is the norm.
It's
difficult and painful to put up with the anti-tobacco attitudes
so many people have today.
Why
choose a path that is just about guaranteed to bring you rejection?
I
don't like the Utter Fool anti-smoking ad. Why? Because
we're calling somebody a fool. It's just not a very effective
way to communicate or persuade. The listener will just tune out
if you call them a name.
I
want to stop for a moment, and talk about how we can better communicate with
each other.
OK,
I need a volunteer. I'd like someone who has a friend or loved
one they want to ask to quit, or to not smoke in the house. The
other requirement is that you be able to give that person two honest compliments. He
selects a volunteer.
Mr Reynolds: So who do you
want to ask to quit smoking, or not smoke in house?
Student: My
Mom.
Mr
Reynolds: Okay, I need a second volunteer to be Mom. Who
wants to be Mom?
He
chooses a student to play Mom. Students often laugh in delight
at this.
Okay.
Do you want to ask Mom here to quit, or just not smoke inside?
Student: To
quit.
Mr
Reynolds: Okay. Start with an honest complement. In general,
that's a good idea whenever you want to say no to anyone about
anything. It's helpful and effective to start with an honest
compliment and a smile, and say, for example, "Hey, Mom,
that dinner you made last night was great!" "Oh,
it was?" Your parent or friend will open up,
and will be all ready to really hear what you have to
say next. Of course, your compliment must be true, honest,
and from your heart. So what's an honest complement to give
Mom, who's standing right here?
Student:
(Thinks) Mom,
I like your hair-do.
Mr
Reynolds: OK, Mom, how does that feel?
Mom: That
feels good!
Mr.
Reynolds (to other student): Now don't use but,
as it totally undoes the nice words you just said. Instead,
use and. Then follow with I feel, and tell
them the emotion you are honestly feeling when you see them
smoke.
Let's
see now, what feelings do we have to choose from? All of us have
six basic emotions the primary colors of our hearts. We've
got (he acts out using facial expressions and tone of voice) anger,
sadness, joy, love, fear and shame. And there's a whole rainbow
of sub-combinations. So what do you feel when you see your Mom
smoke?
Student: I
feel sad.
Mr
Reynolds: Any anger?
Student: Umm,
yes.
Mr
Reynolds: Any fear? For example, that she might die?
Student: Nah.
Mr
Reynolds: So tell Mom here how you feel when you see her
smoke.
Student: Mom,
I feel sad and angry when I see you smoke.
Mr
Reynolds: Now, briefly tell her what you want
her to do.
Student: I
want you to quit.
Mr
Reynolds: Okay,
now we need the second complement.
Student: Um,
I admire how capable you are at work.
Mr
Reynolds: Great! (He
turns to Mom)
Mr
Reynolds: Mom, how does that feel?
Mom: Pretty
good!
Mr
Reynolds (to student): Now put it all together.
Student: Mom,
I like your hair-do, but I —
Mr
Reynolds: No but! Use and. Okay, go again.
Student: Mom,
I like your hair-do, and I feel sad
and angry when I see you smoke. I want you to quit. And I admire
how capable you are at work.
Mr
Reynolds: Excellent! Okay,
Mom, how does that feel?
Mom: I
like it!
Mr
Reynolds: Okay, well done. Let's give these two a round
of applause — it takes courage to come up here! Thanks.
Here are some answers other students have given:
"Dad,
I love the time you spend with me, like when you take me fishing
with you, or come to see me play in the game. Your giving of
your time means so much to me. And when you smoke, I feel afraid
and sad, and a little angry. I need you to stay healthy and
be there for me, and live a really long time. I need you, and
I love you a lot!"
"Mom,
that's a nice dress you have on today. And you know, I feel
sad, and a little afraid too, when I see you smoke. I want
you to quit soon! I don't ever want to lose you. I love you
so much!"
"You're
my best friend, and we have a lot of fun hanging out. I feel
afraid when I see you smoke. I'm worried your second hand smoke
will hurt me, and you too. I want you to put out that cigarette
now, please! And you know what? I'm really glad we're friends."
Mr
Reynolds: In summary, if
you call someone a fool, you lose them. They tune out. On
the other hand, if you approach them in a warm, friendly
manner and tell what you're feeling, your friend or loved
one will open up, and really hear what you have to
say.
The
result? You'll be a more effective communicator. It's powerful
and very persuasive to express your feelings, and it feels good,
too. We'll come back to that.
Here's
another anti-smoking ad. Some of you will remember that not so
long ago, the tobacco company my Grandfather started, R.J. Reynolds
Tobacco, used a cartoon camel to promote its Camel brand. Most
of us remember Joe Camel. He was cool, he wore sunglasses, and
he was shown at the beach with girls in bikinis
around him, or in front of fancy sports cars, or playing
the sax, or hanging out at a pool hall called Joe's Place.
Well,
if tobacco advertising told the truth, here's what Joe Camel
would really look like: (Mr. Reynolds shows this anti-smoking
slide.)
-
Art by Adbusters -

Click for
JOE'S LAST WORDS
Joe
is lying down, sick from smoking! He's got a needle in his arm
to get the chemotherapy medicine, whose purpose is to cure, or
at least slow down, his cancer. It made his hair fall out! His
friends are all gone, he's all alone, and his days as an athlete
are over. And he's in terrible, awful pain, and knows he's going
to die.
Joe
might be saying, "I wish I hadn't smoked. I conned a lot
of kids into thinking smoking was cool, and I'm sorry! And I'm
sorry I smoked. I'm dying of cancer. Just look at me now! Please whatever
you do, don't smoke!"
So
that's what tobacco ads would look like, if they told the truth
about tobacco and smoking.
He
also shows slides of more recent ad campaigns targeting youth,
including several of those below.
"How
do you feel about their going after youth?" he asks, as
he shows several of the images below.
In October, 2006, R.J. Reynolds finally agreed to take its candy-flavored cigarettes almost completely off the market, and to stop running ads associating them with alcoholic beverages.
Ads for R.J. Reynolds Candy-flavored Camel Cigarettes
Click each ad for a larger view.
Ads
for Brown & Williamson's Kool Cigarettes
Click each ad for a larger view.
The toll of smoking
in the US
and around the world
Some
teens are not so concerned about the risk of disease later in
life. But the fact is, cigarettes cause emphysema, lung cancer
and heart disease, and 4 out of every 10 smokers later die from
their addiction to tobacco. Nearly all of them got hooked as
teens.
According
to a new US Surgeon General's Report issued in May, 2004, smoking
is even worse than previously thought. It damages virtually
every organ in the body.
In
the US, smoking causes 1 of every 5 deaths. Cigarettes kill
1,200 Americans every day a tragic death toll of 420,000
Americans each year.
Around
the world, smoking now kills five million people every year.
In the US, 22.5% of adults, or a bit more than one in five,
are addicted to smoking. But because smoking rates in Europe
and Asia are so much higher, on average, one in three adults
worldwide smoke. And smoking kills 4 out of every 10 smokers.
If
we do the math, this means that in coming decades, cigarettes
will actually kill 500 million people and all of them
have already been born. That's nine percent of the present
world population. It means that almost 1 of every 10 people
now alive on earth will die because of tobacco use. These statistics
come from the United Nations World Health Organization, headquartered
in Geneva, Switzerland.
Every
day in the US, 2,000 teens become newly addicted to smoking.
Think about it: most will not be able to quit for 17 years,
and over 800 of those teens will later die from cigarettes.
How
do you feel about that?
More about tobacco
advertising
Let's
take a closer look at cigarette advertising. Would you object
to being manipulated mentally? Well, tobacco ads are designed
to play with your mind.
In
January, 1998, Democratic Congressman Henry Waxman revealed some
very secret memos of the RJ Reynolds Tobacco Company. In 1975,
one executive wrote, "The Camel Brand must increase its
share penetration among the 14 - 24 age group which represent
tomorrow's cigarette business." Tell me, what feelings do
you have about that?
A
1986 memo noted how the cartoon camel campaign would utilize "peer
acceptance/influence" to "motivate the target audience
to take up cigarettes." How does that make you feel? I feel
sad and angry about it.
Your conscious mind vs. your
unconscious mind
So
many teens tell me that tobacco ads have had absolutely no influence
over them. I agree that tobacco ads will not change your conscious mind but
they may be getting through to your unconscious mind
more than you realize.
What
is the unconscious mind? While your conscious mind is analytical,
and makes (mostly!) sensible, rational decisions, it's your unconscious
mind that often throws common sense out the window. It's the
creative part of our minds, and it cares little for right or
wrong. It just knows what feels good or bad, regardless of the
consequences.
For
example, an overweight person may have made a responsible and
conscious decision to diet, but their unconscious mind still
remembers the sweet taste of ice cream. The conscious mind's
will to diet can be overcome by the power of the unconscious
mind, and the memory of delicious ice cream. "Willpower" is
literally the conscious will's power to repeatedly resist the
strong desires of the unconscious mind.
The story of Pavlov and his
dog
The
Russian scientist Pavlov used to ring a bell every time he fed
his dog. Every day he would ring the same bell to call the dog
to his supper. This went on for many months. One day, he accidentally
forgot to put the food out, but rang the bell, thinking he had.
The dog came running, wagging its tail, and Professor Pavlov
was amazed to see the dog drooling — its mouth watering,
as though the scent of food were in the air.
Pavlov
realized that his dog had made an unconscious association
between the sound of the bell and the smell of supper. His dog
was salivating simply upon hearing the bell! He had "conditioned" his
dog.
In
much the same way, the cigarette ads we see in magazines build
an unconscious association, conditioning us to make
a connection between the deadly addiction of smoking and strong,
positive images. In magazine ads, we see healthy young people
playing sports which require breath, like tennis, windsurfing
or mountain climbing. We see beautiful country scenes with campfires,
or wild horses galloping. We see attractive, adult role models
many teens would like to emulate manly cowboys gathered
in friendship around a campfire and successful, independent
and attractive women, who are role models for young girls.
How
many weeks did Pavlov have to ring his bell before his dog finally
drooled just hearing it, even though there was no food there?
It didn't take too long.
Through
most of the 1990's, the tobacco industry spent about $5 billion
each year advertising its deadly, addictive products. Incredibly,
in 1999, they increased that amount by over 50% to
$8 billion per year.
In
2000, they spent $9 billion on advertising, and in 2005, a staggering
$15 billion. That's a lot of bell ringing, ladies and gentlemen!
Cigarettes
are the most heavily advertised product in the world. Tobacco
advertising is a huge lie, and a deceptive manipulation on a
massive scale. And all that advertising sends a powerful message
to our unconscious minds, including the minds of our kids.
The
sad truth is that cigarette ads have a much stronger effect on
teens than most consciously realize.
In
summary, the tobacco industry knows exactly what they are doing,
and they spend billions every year to manipulate the unconscious
minds of millions. Don't let them manipulate you!
The truth about
countertop displays
Day
after day, year after year, you've seen countertop tobacco displays
in convenience stores and grocery
stores. In some States, they're still sitting right on the countertops.
In others, they passed laws to keep them behind the counter,
out of reach of kids. Either way, cigarette and chewing tobacco
displays seem to be everywhere, and in full view.
A
quick show of hands, please how many of you already
knew that the stores get up to $100 per month for each countertop
display of tobacco in the store? [Typically] I see that
almost none of you knew this.
Let's
tell the truth today. The store managers don't put tobacco displays
there because they think smoking is cool. Tobacco displays are
there for only one reason the store owners get paid money
each month by the cigarette companies to keep them there.
In
recent years, the tobacco industry has spent a large share of
its multi-billion dollar ad budget on these deceptive displays.
Tobacco ads are no longer permitted on radio or TV, and there
are less tobacco ads in magazines and newspapers. Tobacco billboards
were removed in the late 1990's, as part of the settlement of
the lawsuit by the States against Big Tobacco. In addition to
billboards, Big Tobacco withdrew its use of promotional T-shirts
and hats, which had turned many kids into little tobacco billboards.
But
even with the elimination of all that tobacco marketing, the
tobacco industry still managed to spend $15 billion
on advertising in 2005!
In-store countertop tobacco displays are now a huge part
of that spending. Another big part of that spending comes in
the form of temporary discounts on cigarettes, which make a pack of smokes much cheaper.
When the price of tobacco is lower, who do you think is more likely to try smoking, and later get hooked? You guessed it -- kids. I
believe it's good to open your eyes about this.
How
are tobacco displays deceptive? Well, you've been going into
convenience and grocery stores since you were little, and you may remember seeing cigarette
displays right in your face on countertops, at child eye level every day.
Tobacco displays make it appear to children that cigarettes
are a perfectly normal product, like chewing gum or candy, and that tobacco is a customary and usual part of adult life.
Often, tobacco products were placed right next to the gum or candy, where kids were sure to look. Today they are behind the counter in most states, but the displays are still prominent, and still make tobacco look like just another product.
In the early days, spit
tobacco displays also created the false impression among the
young that chewing tobacco was popular. Many young people thought, Lots
of customers must be buying chewing tobacco, because if the
store puts them right on the countertop or in plain view, they
must be pretty popular products.
The
truth is that not so many years ago, almost no one was using
chew tobacco. These displays made it appear to be a product
that was selling very well and this was a key element
of the campaign to re-popularize chewing tobacco.
Tobacco
displays, much like the ads in magazines, also foster the false
impression among both youth and adults that smoking is socially
acceptable. This inaccurate perception will continue, sadly,
as long children grow up seeing tobacco displays almost everywhere.
Today being a non-smoker is the norm
Almost
four out of five people in the USA don't smoke. It's just not okay to
smoke around most people, and it's illegal to smoke indoors
in more and more places across our nation.
As
of the election of November, 2006, seventeen States have now passed strong
statewide laws requiring 100% smokefree restaurants, bars, nightclubs and other workplaces.
In 2005, five States joined that list, far more than in any previous
year.
In 2006, eight more States signed on, bringing the current
total to 17. Banning smoking 100% appears to be an idea whose
time has come, and it's tremendously popular with the public
as well.
Review Smoking
is much less socially acceptable than the advertising leads
teens to believe. The tobacco companies spent $15 billion on advertising
in 2005 up from only $5 billion annually just a few
years before. A very substantial part of that is
being spent on in-store displays and temporary discounts.
Tobacco
ads falsely suggest it's okay to smoke around friends, and
create the impression that more people smoke than actually
do smoke. Tobacco advertising disguises tobacco as
a normal American product. Don't buy it! More and more teens are strongly anti-smoking. The rate of teen smoking has greatly declined in many states; in California, only 11% of teens smoke. Adults, too, often
speak up about their anti-tobacco feelings. People just don't want to be in the same room with
smokers.
Two Recent Scientific
Studies
If
you're a teen who believes advertising has no effect on you,
consider this: one recent study demonstrated that advertising
plays a greater role than peer pressure in getting teens to smoke.
Another
recent study proved that the three most heavily advertised
brands are the same three brands most chosen by teens Camels,
Marlboros and Newport. If you smoke, which brand do you usually
use? Probably, you use one of these three.
So Why Is Cigarette Advertising
Legal?
The First Amendment
So
many teens have asked me, "So how come tobacco advertising
is legal, if smoking is so bad for you? Why don't they just ban
tobacco ads?" Here's why.
The
Constitution, of course, is the historic document which created
our great system of government. After completing it, the great
men who wrote it realized they needed to add on to it, or amend
it. The First Amendment provided for Freedom of Speech.
The
First Amendment means
that if I choose, I can stand up on this stage and say publicly, The
sky is purple! In my opinion, it's purple, and the clouds are
green! But if I lie, I will probably not sell too many videos
or books, and the market will quickly sweep me aside.
Nonetheless,
Freedom of Speech protects my right to say what I like in public.
Sadly, it also protects the tobacco industry's right to say what
they like in their advertising, and to place tobacco displays
in stores.
The
world is not a perfect place. That's one of the messages in my
initiation into life, which I'll give you before we say goodbye.
Until now, we adults have done our best to shield your eyes from
the bad in the world. It's time to gently open your eyes to the
fact that there is indeed some bad out there. In my opinion,
tobacco advertising is part of that, and it should be banned
or severely restricted. A private citizen should have every right
to free speech, of coursed. But to my mind, advertising is
quite a different kind of speech.
So
for now, just because you see tobacco products in stores in attractive
displays, it doesn't mean cigarettes are a normal, acceptable
American product like chewing gum or candy.
Let
this knowledge empower you. Remember what I have said when you
see tobacco ads and displays in stores.
Freedom
of Speech was originally intended to protect every citizen's
right to say in public whatever they wanted to say.
Most
judges in our present court system agree that the First Amendment
protects the advertising equally with private speech. One
day, however, I have faith that the Supreme Court will see these forms of speech as separate and
different, and will pass much stronger limits on tobacco ads — also because tobacco represents such an unusual hazard to the health of our
young.
Almost no one over the age of 19 becomes addicted to tobacco.
New smokers are almost always children and teens and tobacco
is a product as addicting as heroin or cocaine.
A further Initiation:
Campaign donations to politicians
The
second reason why I believe tobacco advertising has not been
limited more by Congress is about money: the tobacco industry
has given millions to politicians' election campaigns. The
world is not a perfect place again, this is part of
my initiation into life.
The
tobacco companies have spent tremendous amounts of money on lobbying
Congress, political advertising and campaign donations to politicians'
election funds. Big Tobacco was the No. 1 contributor in the
1996 and 2000 Presidential elections. A new campaign finance
reform law took effect in November, 2002. This helped, but many
political contributors have simply channeled their money into
PAC groups.
Politicians
and their parties mostly use such donations to run their election
ads on TV, in hopes of being elected. They insist that the money
they accept for their campaigns has no influence over the way
they vote.
But
recent studies have shown that members of Congress who accepted
donations from the tobacco industry were several times more likely
to vote the way the tobacco companies wanted them to.
The
truth is that no corporation gives away millions of dollars
without expecting something in return. Any executive who gave
money away for no good reason would promptly be fired! Strengthening
our campaign finance reform law even more should, in my view,
be one of the highest priorities for the US Congress and our President.
Thanks
in large part to continuing political donations, Congress has
done nothing in the past 30 years to limit tobacco advertising,
and next to nothing to raise the Federal cigarette tax. And Congress
has failed to make it harder for youth to buy cigarettes, failed
to legislate FDA regulation of tobacco, and failed to limit smoking
in the workplace.
In
fact, the biggest progress we have made against Big Tobacco did
not come from Congress, which of course is within the legislative
branch of our government. It came mostly from our court system,
or judicial branch. For example, in 1998, there was a $246 billion
settlement of the States' lawsuits.
We
have made progress in only a handful of State legislatures; the
tobacco companies remain powerful even at the State level. However,
we made great progress at the local level our city councils
and municipal governments.
Big
Tobacco's settlement of the States' lawsuits resulted in an agreement
to end cigarette billboards, and the t-shirts and hats that turned
so many kids into little tobacco billboards. Tobacco may still
be advertised in magazines and newspapers, and may still be displayed
on countertops in stores.
Our
progress ending cigarette billboards and "gear" came
from the courts, as a result of the settlement of the tobacco
lawsuits. It did not come from Congress.
In
summary, it's far from a perfect world out there. Sadly, our
politicians are too often influenced by special interest money.
I believe this will change.
There
are some good politicians who are presently more open to change,
who are trying to reform our system of campaign finance. Some
of my esteemed colleagues in the anti-tobacco movement are working
hard for this, as well as for new anti-smoking laws.
In
conclusion, just because you see tobacco ads in magazines, and
displays in convenience stores, it doesn't mean that tobacco
is acceptable or safe. The world isn't perfect! So be smart don't
let these deceptive tobacco ads mislead you.
Dip Tobacco
Chewing
tobacco was popular around 1900, but after cigarettes became
fashionable, less and less people used dip tobacco, and it
nearly disappeared. By the 1950's and 60's, very few people chewed.
When
the U.S. Tobacco Company began their ad campaign to re-launch
their chewing tobacco products, they advertised on TV and in
print media. But they did something few people knew about.
Earlier,
I asked for a quick show of hands to see how many of you already
knew that the tobacco companies pay stores around $100 per month,
often more, to keep those displays of tobacco on their
countertops,
or just behind them. We saw that very few of you were aware of
this.
Ads
for U.S. Smokeless Tobacco Co.
Click the ad for a larger image.
US
Tobacco and others paid grocery stores and convenience stores
all across the nation huge amounts of money to place chewing
tobacco displays on store countertops everywhere. Without
those payments from Big Tobacco, countertop displays of tobacco
products would quickly be removed.
As
we discussed earlier in the section about tobacco advertising,
countertop dip tobacco displays created a false impression among
too many young people. Many assumed, Lots of people must want
these products. If the store puts them right on the countertop,
they must be popular. Dip became popular in large part because
young people were deceived into thinking it was a popular product,
and also acceptable. After all, there was the dip tobacco, right
on the countertop — often alongside the chewing gum and
candy, where the eyes of children are sure to look.
Many
of our young see tobacco displays every day, and have since they
were very small. Do you remember seeing them?
Millions
of kids got fooled. Day after day, month after month, year after
year, seeing those displays in convenience stores, many were
curious and eventually tried dip. Too many then became addicted
and of course, regular customers. And U.S. Tobacco began making
big profits.
Another
problem with these displays was, it was far
too easy for youth to steal cigarettes or chewing tobacco. They
often faced conveniently away from the cashier, where tobacco
was easy for kids to shoplift.
In
some States, laws have been passed requiring stores to keep the
displays behind the counter, out of reach. In some States, they
are starting to cover them with plastic.
But
the tobacco displays are still right on the countertops in many
States. And either way, they are often at child eye level.
How
do you feel about that? It makes me angry and sad, and my
feelings help me renew my commitment to the anti-smoking cause.
I
personally believe that to protect our youth, 'spit' tobacco,
along with cigarettes, should be kept under the counter, totally
unseen by customers. The old saying applies: out of sight, out
of mind. Then only already-addicted, existing customers would
think to ask for these deadly products by name. For now, though, Freedom of Speech protects tobacco advertising.
The
U.S. Tobacco Company makes several brands of spit tobacco. The
one many kids start out on is Cherry Skoal. It has the weakest
nicotine bite, and is sweetened with cherry flavoring a
taste not unlike candy. And these products are often placed next
to the candy in convenience stores.
Many
who try it become addicted, and usually move on to another brand
with more nicotine, to satisfy their powerful new cravings. U.S.
Tobacco makes several brands, with varying amounts of nicotine.
The brand with the most nicotine is Copenhagen. US Tobacco actually
had the gall to take out one ad which read, "Sooner or later,
it's Copenhagen!"
A True Story
about Spit Tobacco
Sean
Marsee had won 28 medals at track meets. He was a very popular
and respected athlete at his high school. Thinking it was safe,
Sean began chewing dip tobacco in his mid-teens.
One
day Sean came home and his Mom noticed a bulge in his lower lip. "What's
that, son?" she asked him. A little embarrassed, Sean said,
"Well,
uh, I been dippin', Mom. Hey, my teammates do it."
"Son,
you've always been a responsible boy. I'm sure you'll make a
smart choice about this." She smiled bravely.
A
few days later, Sean came home and told his Mom, "Mom, I
thought about it, and I'm gonna quit, no problem." A few
days passed, and Sean came home. This day he looked troubled.
"I
tried to quit the dip, Mom. I can't do it."
"That's
ok, son, try again. I believe in you."
But
Sean tried again, and failed to quit. He tried again and again,
but he could not stop.
His
mother Betty was a registered nurse. She begged her son to quit,
but he was just unable to.
It
was Sean who had rescued his younger sister last winter, when
she fell through the ice on the lake. He was the hero of the
family, and he was increasingly respected in the town, also for
his success on the track field. He was becoming a man now, and
she had to let him make his own choices. So after a while, Betty
gave up trying.
A
few months passed. One day Sean came home and told his mother, "Mom,
my tongue hurts."
"OK,
son, let me see." He showed Betty a red sore the size of
a half dollar on his tongue, with a hard white core in the middle.
"Oh
my," she said. "We'd better get you to the doctor." At
the hospital, the doctor performed some tests.
A
few days later, Sean was lounging around the house watching TV,
like he always did. The the phone rang, and he heard his mother
answer in her bedroom, like she always did. A few minutes later,
he heard his mother's muffled sobs through her closed door. He
went into her room, and softly put his hand on her shoulder. "What's
wrong, Mom?"
"Son,
you have cancer in your tongue," she sobbed. They went back
to the hospital, where Sean was shocked to learn he had to have
most of his tongue cut out. He would never be able to talk again.
He was 18 years old.
"Can
I still run in the track meet on Friday?" he asked the doctor
in a slightly trembling voice. The doctor said, "Yes son,
you can run in the track meet on Friday. But after that, I need
you to come in here." I don't know how he did that day,
whether he won or lost, but he did his best, which is what sport
is. After the meet, Sean went in for the operation to remove
much of his tongue.
People
from the town sent cookies and cakes to the Marsee family, but
Sean had a feeding tube up his nose and down into his stomach.
He could not chew food. Visitors dropped by the house to visit
him and his sisters, and his coach brought friends by after practice.
But
the cancer did not go away. It spread to Sean's jaw and neck
muscles. Two more operations would follow. Sean had to have much
of his jaw bone removed, along with part of his nose, and some
neck muscles on one side.
This
was a boy who hated getting even a pimple, and kept his hair
meticulously combed! He took great pride in his physical appearance.
Now he felt ashamed.

Sean
Marsee at age 17 |

Sean
Marsee at age 19, just prior to his death |
Patrick
shows these overheads
as he tells Sean Marsee's story.
At
age 19, Sean lay in bed, sad and in pain. His best friend, who
had been told Sean didn't have much longer to live, came down
from Chicago to see him for the last time. On first seeing Sean,
his friend fought back tears, thinking of the great times he'd
never get to have with Sean.
The
next day, as they visited, he asked, "Sean, what if we took
a photo of you like this?" But Sean shook his head, glaring,
and wrote down emphatically, "No, not like this!" He
was overcome with shame and embarrassment at the idea.
But
his friend persisted, "What if other teens could see the
photo, and learn the truth about what chewing tobacco really
does?" Sean reflected on this for a while. Finally he allowed
this picture to be taken, with his track medals pinned to his
chest. It's his gift to you.
His
friend got another idea. "Sean, what if, by some miracle,
you could get a message to other teens? Do you have any words
you'd like them to hear?" Sean nodded because without
his tongue he could not talk and he gestured for pen and
paper. His hands trembled and his eyes welled as he began to
write, perhaps in part from the pain he was in. He struggled
to write down these words, as his message to all of you: "Don't
dip snuff."
And
not too long after that, Sean expressed a simple affirmation
of his Christian faith, and died sad, disfigured, and
in terrible, unspeakable pain.
So
let's take a last look at these pictures, and thank The American
Cancer Society, Sean's family, and most of all, Sean himself,
for this gift. We will remember you, Sean Marsee, and learn by
your tragic death at age 19. We will remember.
The
story of Sean Marsee is available in greater detail here.
Our
thanks to the Marsee family
for allowing us to reproduce these photos. We were pleased
to see that a USA
Today anti-smoking column wrote of our presentation of
Sean's story, "This was probably the most effective argument
found online."
The
best website on chewing tobacco is The
Patchproject -- check it out. It includes terrific quitting
tips and plenty of truly horrendous photos of disease caused
by dip.
WARNING
If
Sean Marsee's story moved you, the before and after photos of Bryan
Curtis are
even more powerful and moving. This link is not for the faint of heart!
Summary and Review
Chewing
tobacco was made to look like a popular product when the U.S.
Tobacco Company paid convenience stores to place their addictive
products on countertops. Thousands of teens across the country
assumed that chewing tobacco must be really popular. Eventually
many teens tried it, and soon became addicted.
Remember,
six out of every ten U.S. smokers started smoking before
age 14. Nine of every ten smokers became addicted before
reaching age 19.
In
other words, almost no one will start smoking after 19! Nearly
all of the tobacco industry's new customers are teens. Who are
the only new recruits the tobacco companies can get? It's you the
young. How do you feel about that?
Be
smart, and don't be fooled. And remember how very addicting tobacco
really is.
On How To Study
[For
middle schools:] I'm going to ask you a question in a
moment. But first, I want you to keep your eyes me, stay very
quiet and not talk to your neighbor. You guys are being so
great today! That's how we learn, we keep our eyes on the teacher,
don't talk to friends, and listen. When we listen to the teacher,
we learn.
[For
high schools and middle schools:] When we don't understand
something the teacher says, the students who will succeed best
in school raise their hands and ask questions. Remember, people
who succeed best at life get help. To review, in business,
a successful businessperson gets a lawyer to write the contracts,
an advertising agency to create the ads, a doctor when they're
sick, and so on. People who succeed ask for help. Ask your
teachers and parents questions it's good to ask, and
it's okay to ask. Real men do ask for directions!
By
the way, how do we study? It's called Butt Power you keep
your butt in the chair and your nose in the book. Excellence
takes just a little extra effort and focus. Highlighting is good,
and if you have time, go back and read what you highlighted again.
And always ask questions when you don't understand.
We
hear a good deal lately about the excessive homework being assigned
today. If enough families speak up, schools will respond, and
we will see change. So let your feelings be known about that.
On Ethics
In
the past, it has been far too easy for children to steal cigarettes.
All the tobacco companies had to do is to sit back and wait until
they got addicted. It only takes 2 weeks in many cases. When
you do get hooked, your cigarette addiction will cost you $1,200
per year or more to maintain and it's possible you might
never be able to stop.
So
here's my question. Let's see a show of hands: How many of you
know of a friend who has stolen cigarettes ? [In most middle
and high schools, from 1/4 or more of the hands go up.]
That
makes me feel sad. Let's have a talk about ethics. I'm going
to give you three good reasons to be honest.
First,
there's our relationship with our community. It really hurts
our community when we are dishonest and that means it
hurts the people around us. It hurts our parents, our friends,
and our neighbors. And we hurt ourselves, too.
The
fact is, we are all models of ethical leadership for each
other. When we do the right thing, we lead our friends in
a good and honest direction. You influence your friends positively
when you refuse to use cigarettes, drugs, or alcohol. If you
steal, you lead your friends in a dishonest direction. And your
example really does influence your friends. If you say yes to
these things, you're hurting yourself and your friends.
Second,
how we feel about ourselves is really important. One of the
best reasons I know to be honest is that it just plain feels
good. And it feels bad when we do something we know to be
dishonest. For example, it's so painful to hide and tell a lie,
or to keep a deep, dark secret when we have done something wrong.
Guilt and shame are very uncomfortable to bear. They're very
costly emotions. Telling the truth, and being honest, lightens
our load and sets us free.
It's
really very simple. It just plain feels so good to be honest.
On Secrets
[For
middle schools:] Mostly I don't like secrets the
secrets of your best friends your own age are okay. But if
you're carrying a deep, dark secret, or feel like you have
done something really wrong, it can feel like you're carrying
around a 100 pound weight everywhere you go.
Find
the courage to talk to your parents about it! It will be okay!
If you can't bring yourself to talk to your parents, then talk
to a trusted teacher, or to the school counselor. That's what
they're there for, and it's 100% okay and so good to talk
to them.
Don't
carry a huge secret alone it's too hard. When you talk
to someone, it's like setting that 100 pound weight down, and
suddenly you're free of it. So don't hold back. Don't carry your secret silently, what EVER it may be. Remember, students
who succeed best usually get help -- so speak up and talk to another person!
Telling the truth really does set us free.
What Can I Do
If My Parents Smoke?
I
get asked this a good deal, and my answer might surprise you don't
be a NAG about their smoking habit!
That's
right don't be an anti-smoking fanatic! Instead, ask for
reasonable changes.
For
example, it's appropriate to let your anti-smoking feelings be
known if someone smokes in the house or near you. It's okay to
speak up because their second hand smoke hurts you.
But
don't nag them to stop smoking. There's a big difference!
That
said, it's okay to ask family members to quit smoking but
I'd recommend asking them no more than three times a year. Be
brief, and try to use loving tones and words. Sandwich your request
between honest compliments, and family members and friends will
become more open to hearing you.
We've
already seen a fine example of this today, in the earlier demonstration
with the volunteers who so bravely joined me up here.
If
you ask a loved one to quit more than three times per year, you're
a yucky, obnoxious nag! If you deliver your anti-smoking
feelings more than this, you may make them so angry that they
will keep on smoking, just out of anger and stubbornness.
So honor your
smoking loved ones, and treat them like adults. Don't harass
them about their habit, or nag them with your anti-smoking views.
Let them decide to quit smoking by themselves, when they get
ready. That's often the best way to open the door for them to
stop.
You
do, however, get to be a pest about second hand smoke. That
hurts you, so it's your business. But you don't get to nag
a loved one to quit their addiction.
Examples of how
to ask
a friend or loved one to quit
Remember,
like we did in the demonstration, sandwich your "No" between
100% honest, positive statements. Do your best to talk about
your feelings speak from your heart. For example,
"I
love being your friend, and I value our friendship. And I
feel angry when you smoke. I don't want to lose you. I want
us both to live for a very long time."
"Hey,
Dad, thanks for taking me to the game last Saturday. I had a
great time with you. And you know, I get afraid when I
see you smoking. I need you to live a long time. I love you,
Dad." The key is to express what you are really feeling.
"Mom,
that dinner you made last night was great! And I feel sad when
you smoke. I really love you, and I need you so much!
Honest complements motivate people
Try
a complement like this one: "Dad,
you're wise and responsible. I'm sure you'll quit smoking whenever
you get ready, and when you get around to it. I feel happy when
I remind myself, of course you'll make a smart choice
about tobacco! I have so much faith in you I just think
you're the greatest, Dad!"
|